Cutler Bay Homes for Sale
… homes for sale · Median $480K–$700K · · South Dade's Premier Family Community
Live MLS Listings
Cutler Bay Homes for Sale
About Cutler Bay
Cutler Bay, Florida
Cutler Bay is a thriving South Miami-Dade municipality that has established itself as one of the region’s most desirable family communities, offering a thoughtful combination of affordability, natural beauty, and community character. Incorporated as a town in 2005, Cutler Bay is located along the southeastern coast of Miami-Dade, bordered by Palmetto Bay to the north, Homestead to the south, and Biscayne Bay and Black Point Marina to the east.
Cutler Bay is served by ZIP codes 33157, 33158, and 33189, and is home to approximately 45,000 residents. The town encompasses Cutler Ridge—a well-established community dating to the 1960s—as well as newer developments including Lakes by the Bay, Old Cutler Bay, and Saga Bay. Black Point Park and Marina provides exceptional boating access to Biscayne Bay and the Florida Keys.
For families seeking more space, safety, and natural surroundings than northern Miami-Dade can offer at a reasonable price, Cutler Bay consistently delivers. Explore all Miami communities →
📊 Cutler Bay at a Glance
Why Cutler Bay
Market Highlights
Exceptional Value
More home for your money compared to Palmetto Bay or Pinecrest — single-family homes from $480K with larger lots and newer construction.
Bay Access
Black Point Marina is the gateway to Biscayne National Park and the Florida Keys, offering world-class boating and fishing.
Military Demand
Homestead Air Reserve Base drives strong, consistent rental tenant base from military families and essential workers.
Parks & Nature
Extensive parks system with sports fields, natural areas, and sweeping bay views — South Dade at its most livable.
Education
Schools in Cutler Bay
Cutler Bay is served by A-rated elementary schools including Cutler Ridge Elementary and Caribbean Elementary. Cutler Bay Middle School and Cutler Bay Senior High School round out the public school options, with charter and private options in neighboring Palmetto Bay also accessible.
🏫 Elementary Schools
📚 Middle Schools
🎓 High Schools
All schools are part of Miami-Dade County Public Schools. School ratings reflect Florida Department of Education grades. Verify current boundaries with MDCPS before purchasing.
Common Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Find Your Cutler Bay Home?
Cutler Bay’s competitive market demands a local expert. Marie Sanjurjo’s 20+ years of Miami-Dade experience gives you the edge to find and secure the right property at the right price.